Skip to main content

Open Access: Predatory Publishers and Assessing a Journal

Think. Check. Submit video

What is Predatory or Deceptive Publishing?

Predatory publishers operate in many ways, using academics' need to have research outputs and disseminate their research (through, for example, publishing or presenting at conferences) to extort money.  Academics can be spammed and invited to publish with the promise of quick and easy publication. Fake journals with titles similar to legitimate ones are one of the methods used in the scams. Authors are invited to publish and asked for a fee upfront.  Then, their paper is either published, without any editorial work, in a journal with little or no credibility within scholarly circles or not published at all. In some cases people have been invited to present at fake conferences. These scams are sophisticated and may link to websites that initially look legitimate. The scams evolve rapidly so there is a need to be vigilant, question and investigate to avoid being a victim.

Two useful resources are the OASPA (Online Open Access Scholarly Publishers Association) website which has lists of legitimate Open Access journals and the Think,Check Submit guide that provides advice to researchers on questions to ask before deciding to publish in a particular journal.  It is important that researchers make an informed choice on where to publish. 

Previously there has been some reliance on lists of journal titles and publishers who were seen as not following ethical processes or not adhering to trustworthy models.  Beall's List was the best known list, it had lists of publishers and journal titles, this list is no longer being actively curated so will become out of date over time, you can access an archived version of it here.

The research community needs to use scholarly social networks to identify and share information on publishers that deceive, lack transparency or otherwise fail to follow industry standards.

 We recommend a thorough approach when considering publication.  You can contact Tuapapa Rangahau or the Library's Knowledge Specialist team for further information.

Assessing a journal or publisher